4 Comments

Fascinating. Loved the article and your commentary.

Expand full comment

Thank you Barry for reading the article and sharing your thoughts about my commentary. In general, even though takedown pieces garner more engagement (sadly), I prefer articles with nuance and thought! (I'm a little tired of either-or thinking.)

Expand full comment

As an educator and librarian, I spent a lot of time discussing this article with friends and colleagues and was delighted to see you feature it today. THANK YOU!

Expand full comment

Hi Katy, and sorry it has taken me so long to reply to your comment. Is your education experience in elementary schools? The reason I ask is that sometimes I wonder if I would be anti-Lucy had I taught the earlier grades (and been advised to use her curriculum). Thank you for reading and supporting Article Club!

Expand full comment