Feb 9, 2020 • 3M

Paul Tough, Week 2: Let’s share our first impressions of “Getting an A,” plus our questions and the topics we want to explore

Mark Isero
4
5
 
1.0×
0:00
-3:08
Open in playerListen on);
    Substack App
    Get a private RSS link for listening
    Subscribe to The Highlighter Article Club to get a private link for listening in your favorite podcast player. Learn about RSS.
Why are there so many book clubs and so few article clubs? Let’s change that! Join The Highlighter Article Club, where we read, annotate, and discuss one outstanding article every month on race, education, or culture.
Episode details
5 comments

Hi there, Article Clubbers, and welcome to the many new members who joined this week. It’s great to see how quickly we’re growing. This month, we’re discussing Paul Tough’s “Getting an A,” a chapter from his outstanding book, The Years That Matter Most: How College Makes or Breaks Us.

Last week, we read (and some of us vigorously annotated) the chapter. This week, we’ll begin our discussion by sharing our first impressions, questions, and topics we want to explore. If we have questions for Mr. Tough, we’ll include those, too.

If you’re new to Article Club: I’m happy you’re here! In the comments, say hi and introduce yourself. Then I’ll email you the chapter so you can join the discussion.

OK, it’s time to discuss!

  • What were your first impressions of “Getting an A”?

  • What questions do you have — for the group or for Mr. Tough?

  • What topics do you want us to explore more?

In the comments, say hi and share your thoughts. Remember, there’s no need to be smart here: Just go for it. Enjoy getting to know your fellow Article Club friends, reply to one another’s ideas, and build off one another. Most of all, have fun!

Coming up this month

  • Next Sunday, Feb. 16: Mr. Tough will answer our questions as part of a podcast episode. We’ll reflect on what he says and deepen our conversation.

  • Sunday, Feb. 23: We’ll convene in person (1-2:30 pm in Oakland) or online (4-5 pm PT via Zoom) to discuss “Getting an A” in depth.

One last thing: I want to thank Mr. Tough for getting the word out and encouraging his followers to join Article Club. I look forward to asking you our questions soon!

Twitter avatar for @paultoughPaul Tough @paultough
I’m taking part this month in a cool new experiment in community reading: Article Club, an online (and occasionally in-person) gathering that reads and discusses a different article or book chapter each month. Last month's author was @jiatolentino... 1/2 Article ClubWe read and discuss one great article every month. Join us!articleclub.substack.com

February 8th 2020

2 Retweets

Article Club is a new experiment in community reading. We read and discuss one outstanding article or book chapter a month, both online and in person. We invite the author to join our conversation, too. If you’re interested, please sign up and check us out! Article Club is part of The Highlighter, a weekly newsletter featuring the best articles on race, education, and culture.

5